Reference · comparisons · 5 appliances
Air fryer vs other kitchen appliances
Five side-by-side comparisons covering the appliances an air fryer overlaps with — the oven, the convection oven, the deep fryer, the microwave and the toaster oven. Each page breaks down where the basket genuinely wins (crisp, speed, oil, energy) and where the other tool still wins (volume, sustained low heat, liquid batters, top-down broil, the fastest reheat). Use the cards below to jump straight to the comparison that matters; the shorter answer to should I get rid of my X? almost always lives on one of these pages.
vs Conventional oven
Air fryer vs oven
Faster preheat, roughly half the energy per cook, and a perforated basket that crisps the underside of food the way a sheet pan never does — for the small-batch weeknight cook the air fryer wins outright.
- Air fryer wins
- Wings, frozen fries, brussels sprouts, bacon and any single-layer 4-serving roast — basket geometry crisps every face without flipping.
- Conventional oven wins
- Whole turkeys, multi-tray cookie bakes, sheet-pan dinners for six, long low braises above 60 minutes — anywhere capacity or sustained low heat matters more than crispness.
Read the full comparison →
vs Convection oven
Air fryer vs convection oven
Same fan principle, but a far smaller chamber and 5–10× the air velocity make the air fryer crisper on the underside in roughly a quarter of the preheat time. The convection oven still wins on raw volume.
- Air fryer wins
- Single-batch fries, wings, sprouts, bacon — anywhere the underside steaming on a sheet pan is what keeps the convection oven from getting truly crisp.
- Convection oven wins
- Two or three sheet pans of cookies at one temperature, sheet-pan dinners for six, big roasts and any cook that fills more than a 6-quart basket.
Read the full comparison →
vs Deep fryer
Air fryer vs deep fryer
One to two teaspoons of oil instead of one to two cups, roughly 150–200 fewer calories per serving of fries, far less cleanup and the leading source of US home kitchen fires removed from the counter.
- Air fryer wins
- Frozen breaded items, wings, bacon and roasted vegetables — anything that doesn't need 360° fat-contact gets 95% of the deep-fried result with 5% of the mess.
- Deep fryer wins
- Liquid-batter foods — tempura, beer-battered fish, beignets, doughnuts, churros from raw dough — wet batter slumps in moving air and only sets in hot oil.
Read the full comparison →
vs Microwave
Air fryer vs microwave
They solve different problems. The microwave is the fastest reheat in the kitchen; the air fryer is the fastest crisp. Most kitchens keep both — the question is which one each leftover goes in.
- Air fryer wins
- Pizza slices, fried chicken, fries, mozzarella sticks, egg rolls and anything that came out of the air fryer the first time — dry hot air restores the crust the microwave kills.
- Microwave wins
- Plates of pasta, stew, curry, rice bowls, soup, coffee, melted butter and frozen ready-meals — anything wet or sauce-based reheats best in 60–90 seconds in the microwave.
Read the full comparison →
vs Toaster oven
Air fryer vs toaster oven
The basket crisps food on every face, but the toaster oven still owns actual toast, top-down broil, gratin crusts and 4-serving sheet bakes the basket can't fit. Many kitchens keep both — they solve different finishes of heat.
- Air fryer wins
- Wings, fries, brussels sprouts and bacon — the underside crisp the toaster oven's wire rack or sheet pan can't reproduce.
- Toaster oven wins
- Sliced bread, bagels, English muffins, frozen waffles, melts, gratin crusts, 10–12 in pizzas and 9×13 casseroles — anything that needs a dedicated toast cycle or top-down broil.
Read the full comparison →
Where to go next
Not sure the air fryer is the right tool for your cook? These three pages answer the adjacent "should I use the air fryer for this?" question without picking a rival appliance:
FAQ about choosing between an air fryer and its rivals
- Which other kitchen appliance does the air fryer most often replace?
- For the everyday weeknight cook, the toaster oven. Most US kitchens already had a toaster oven on the counter for small-batch reheats and 4-serving sheet bakes, and the air fryer overlaps with that role almost completely while crisping the underside the toaster oven cannot. The oven is the next-most-overlapping appliance, but the oven still wins above the 4-serving line and on long low cooks, so it doesn't actually leave the kitchen — it gets used less. The deep fryer is the appliance the air fryer most often retires outright. The microwave never gets replaced: it does fast wet reheats nothing else can match.
- Should I get rid of my oven once I have an air fryer?
- No. The 4-quart-to-6-quart basket caps useful capacity at around 4 servings; anything that feeds 6 or more, any whole-bird roast above 5 lb, any multi-tray batch bake, and any cook longer than 60 minutes still belongs in the oven. The realistic pattern: the air fryer becomes the daily small-batch tool and the oven becomes the once-a-week tool for weekend roasts, family-size sheet-pan dinners and any bake larger than a 9-inch pizza. Kitchens that try to give up the oven entirely usually re-buy one within a year.
- Is the air fryer faster and cheaper than the oven on every cook?
- Roughly 50% less energy per cook at small batch, and 25–40% faster on a 1 lb cut — but only at small batch. A typical 1 800 W air fryer running for 20 minutes draws about 0.6 kWh; a typical 3 000 W electric oven (preheat plus 30-minute cook) draws about 1.2–1.5 kWh because the larger cavity has to climb and hold temperature across far more thermal mass. At the 2026 US average of $0.16/kWh that's about $0.10 vs $0.20 per cook. The savings shrink as batch size approaches oven capacity: once you're filling the oven cavity efficiently, the energy gap narrows and the oven catches up. Below 4 servings the air fryer is straightforwardly cheaper; above it, the oven wins on per-serving energy.
- If the air fryer is just a convection oven, why is it crisper?
- Chamber size and basket geometry, not fan power. A convection oven moves air with a fan the same way a basket air fryer does, but the air fryer's chamber is one-twentieth the cavity volume and its perforated tray sits the food in moving air on every face — the underside of every piece is exposed to hot moving air, not resting on a metal sheet steaming in its own moisture. Net effect at the food: 5–10× the air velocity of a regular oven, and crisping on every face without a flip. The convection oven still wins anywhere capacity matters more than underside crisp.
- Why can't I use the air fryer for tempura, beignets or wet-batter foods?
- Wet batter sets by direct contact with 350 °F oil. In hot moving air there's nothing to set the batter on contact, so it slumps and drips off the food before it can crisp — you end up with bare protein and a puddle of cooked batter on the bottom of the basket. The fix is the deep fryer, full stop. The list of foods that genuinely need oil immersion is short — tempura, beer-battered fish, beignets, doughnuts, churros from raw dough, true buttermilk-dredged fried chicken, hand-cut blanched-then-fried French fries — but for those specific foods the air fryer is the wrong tool. For everything breaded, frozen-coated or naturally fatty, the air fryer is the everyday tool.
- When does the microwave still beat the air fryer?
- Wet reheats, liquids and steam-based ready-meals. A plate of pasta, stew, curry, mac-and-cheese or any sauce-based leftover reheats in 60–90 seconds in the microwave; the air fryer takes 5–8 minutes for the same task and dries the sauce out. Coffee, tea, milk, melted butter, softened cream cheese and any liquid heat-and-stir job is microwave-only — the air fryer literally cannot heat a mug without baking it dry. Frozen ready-meals built around rice, soup or steamed vegetables also belong in the microwave — wet meals stay wet, which is the point. The air fryer is the right reheat tool only when the original food was crisp.